Gay in America

During my year and a half working on the DIVerse Families collection, I have read many incredible works showcasing diversity. One in particular that has made a lasting impact on me is a photography book called, Gay in America, with photographs taken by Scott Pasfield. This book encompasses a series of portraits and stories of 140 gay men across all 50 states. The photography book depicts gay men of different races, lifestyles, and careers. By doing so, it shatters the stereotypes that usually surround what being a gay man means and shows them in their reality. One of the most striking things about this book is it’s cover. The cover shows a man named Dan Choi, a former army lieutenant and LGBTQ activist, standing in his military uniform. I’m glad Scott put him on the cover to represent this book because in American society today, there is such terrible discrimination of LGBTQ military service members. This stemming from the Don’t Ask Don’t Tell Act from 25 years ago, later repealed, to the transgender ban that is now in effect. This book is real, honest, and doesn’t sugarcoat the ups and downs of what being gay in America means for these men. The series of portraits and stories gave me a realistic view of the lives of gay men in our country, and I hope by others reading this book, it will do the same for them.
Want to see the analysis for Gay in America? Click here to check it out.
Beyond the Frame: The Stories Behind the Portraits
Scott Pasfield spent over three years traveling across the United States to capture the lives of gay men from every walk of life. His approach was not to stage dramatic scenes or sensationalize his subjects, but to meet each man in his own environment—whether that was a farm in Iowa, a boardroom in Manhattan, or a military base in the South. The result is a collection that feels less like a traditional photography book and more like a series of intimate conversations. Each portrait is accompanied by a first-person narrative, allowing the men to speak for themselves about their joys, struggles, families, faith, and careers. This dual format—image and text—invites readers to see the whole person, not just a single identity label.
What makes Gay in America particularly powerful is its refusal to present a monolithic experience. The book includes gay men who are fathers, veterans, artists, athletes, clergy, and blue-collar workers. Some are out and proud; others live in communities where they must hide their sexuality for safety or employment. By including this range, Pasfield challenges the assumption that gay life is the same everywhere. A gay man in San Francisco may have a vastly different daily reality than a gay man in rural Mississippi, and the book honors both truths. This diversity of experience is a crucial reminder that LGBTQ+ identity intersects with geography, race, class, and religion in complex ways.

For readers of the Diverse Families Bookshelf, this book serves as a bridge between personal stories and broader social understanding. It aligns with our mission to highlight books that reflect the real lives of LGBTQ+ individuals and families. If you are looking for more titles that explore gay identity through personal narrative, visit our LGBTQ+ section or browse the LGBTQ+ Archives for reviews and recommendations.
The Photographer's Journey: Scott Pasfield's Vision
Scott Pasfield is not a professional photographer by trade; he is a graphic designer and art director who picked up a camera with a specific purpose. After coming out later in life and witnessing the isolation many gay men feel, he wanted to create a visual record that countered the narrow representations he saw in media. His background in design is evident in the book's clean layout and thoughtful sequencing, but it is his empathy as a gay man himself that gives the portraits their depth. Pasfield has said that the project began as a personal quest to find community—and ended as a national portrait of resilience.
The logistics of the project were daunting. Pasfield funded much of the travel himself, often staying with the men he photographed or relying on word-of-mouth to find subjects. He used a medium-format film camera to capture rich detail and a timeless quality, avoiding the disposable feel of digital snapshots. The resulting images are striking in their simplicity: no elaborate lighting or props, just the person and their environment. This approach strips away artifice and allows the viewer to focus on the eyes, the posture, the small details that reveal character. It is a masterclass in documentary portraiture.
Pasfield's work has been compared to that of photographers like Catherine Opie and Richard Renaldi, who also document LGBTQ+ communities with dignity and nuance. However, Gay in America stands out for its national scope and its explicit pairing of image with personal story. The book is not just a collection of faces; it is an archive of lived experience at a particular moment in American history—the early 2010s, a time of rapid change for LGBTQ+ rights. As such, it serves as both a time capsule and a call to action.

Context and Impact: Gay Life in a Changing America
When Gay in America was published, the United States was in the midst of a profound shift in attitudes toward LGBTQ+ people. The repeal of "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" in 2011 allowed gay and lesbian service members to serve openly, and the Supreme Court's 2015 decision in Obergefell v. Hodges legalized same-sex marriage nationwide. Yet these legal victories did not erase the daily discrimination, family rejection, and violence that many gay men still face. The book captures this tension: portraits of joy and pride sit alongside stories of loss and fear. It is a nuanced document that refuses to paint a rosy picture while also celebrating hard-won progress.
One of the most striking aspects of the book is its inclusion of older gay men, some of whom lived through the AIDS crisis of the 1980s and 1990s. Their stories add historical depth and remind readers that the fight for LGBTQ+ rights is not new. Younger men in the book often express gratitude for the freedoms they enjoy, but also acknowledge the work that remains—particularly for transgender individuals and LGBTQ+ people of color. This intergenerational dialogue is one of the book's quiet strengths, showing how far the community has come and how far it still has to go.
For educators and parents, Gay in America can be a valuable tool for starting conversations about diversity and empathy. The book's format—short, readable narratives paired with powerful images—makes it accessible to teens and adults alike. It pairs well with other titles in our collection that explore gay identity from different angles, such as Brooklyn, Burning for young adult fiction or Star-Crossed for middle-grade romance. Together, these books offer a multi-dimensional view of what it means to be gay in America.
Representation Matters: Why This Book Belongs on Your Shelf
In a media landscape that often reduces gay men to caricatures—the flamboyant best friend, the tragic victim, the hypersexual party boy—Gay in America offers a corrective. Here are ordinary men living ordinary lives: a teacher grading papers, a mechanic under a car, a grandfather holding his grandchild. This normalization is radical in its own way. It says that gay men are not a monolith, and that their sexuality is just one part of who they are. For young LGBTQ+ readers, seeing such varied representations can be life-affirming; for straight readers, it can break down stereotypes and build understanding.

The book also highlights the importance of intersectionality. Gay men in the book are Black, Latino, Asian, Native American, and white. They are disabled, working-class, wealthy, religious, atheist, urban, and rural. Some are immigrants; some are veterans. By showing this diversity, Pasfield underscores that there is no single "gay experience." This aligns with the Diverse Families Bookshelf's commitment to books that reflect the full spectrum of human identity. We believe that every child and family deserves to see themselves in the stories they read, and Gay in America is a powerful example of that principle in action.
If you are building a home or classroom library, consider adding Gay in America alongside other inclusive titles. For younger readers, Aitor Has Two Moms (Aitor Tiene Dos Mamas) offers a gentle introduction to same-sex parents, while Introducing Teddy: A Gentle Story About Gender and Friendship explores gender identity in a child-friendly way. For teens and adults, Gay in America provides a visual and narrative anchor for discussions about identity, community, and resilience.
How to Use This Book in Conversations and Classrooms
Because Gay in America is a photography book, it can be approached in many ways. One effective method is to choose a single portrait and read the accompanying story aloud, then ask open-ended questions: What do you notice about this person? What surprised you about their story? How does their experience compare to your own? This works well in both family settings and high school classrooms. The visual element makes it accessible to visual learners, while the text provides depth for those who prefer reading.
- Use the book as a springboard for discussing LGBTQ+ history, including the AIDS crisis, marriage equality, and military service.
- Pair it with fiction that features gay protagonists, such as Brooklyn, Burning, to compare real-life and imagined experiences.
- Encourage readers to research one of the men featured in the book and present their story to the group.
- Discuss the role of geography in shaping LGBTQ+ experiences—how does living in a rural area differ from an urban one?
- Reflect on the power of photography to humanize marginalized communities and challenge stereotypes.
Ultimately, Gay in America is more than a book; it is a conversation starter, a historical document, and a work of art. It belongs in libraries, schools, and homes where diversity is valued. We encourage you to explore it and the many other titles in our LGBTQ+ collection. Together, these books help build a world where every family and every person is seen, heard, and celebrated.